Congress delegates tariff power to Treasury via hidden tax code amendment
H.R. 591 — Defending American Jobs and Investment Act · Filed by Jason Smith (R-MO) · 25 cosponsors · Introduced Jan 21, 2025 · Referred to committee
Your members of Congress
Enter a ZIP to see where your representative and both senators stood on this bill.
Looked up on this device — your ZIP is never stored on our servers.
What it does
This bill creates a mechanism for the U.S. to identify and punish foreign countries that impose taxes the bill deems 'extraterritorial' or 'discriminatory' against American persons and corporations. The Treasury Department must report every 180 days on which countries have such taxes; 180 days after a country is first listed, the U.S. automatically increases income tax rates on that country's citizens and corporations by 5–20 percentage points (escalating over time), withholds more tax from their payments, and can ban federal procurement from them. The bill also instructs the U.S. to factor these taxes into trade and tax treaty negotiations. The stated beneficiaries are American businesses and investors; the stated cost falls on foreign governments and their nationals doing business in the U.S.
Why we flagged it
The bill functions as an automatic, escalating tariff mechanism embedded in the tax code, bypassing traditional trade negotiation and congressional approval processes. It grants the Executive Branch broad discretion to identify 'discriminatory' taxes and impose punitive tax increases without requiring legislative action for each country or each escalation step.
What the text implies
- The bill defines 'discriminatory tax' so broadly (e.g., any tax applied predominantly to nonresidents, or any tax not computed on net income) that it may capture routine foreign tax policies, including value-added taxes and withholding taxes on dividends—standard international practice—potentially triggering automatic U.S. retaliation against dozens of trading partners.
- The 'applicable date' mechanism creates a 180-day grace period after first reporting, then automatic escalation to 5%, 10%, 15%, then 20% rate increases without further congressional action, effectively delegating tariff authority to the Executive Branch and Treasury.
The full analysis lists 5 implications of this text.
Who stands to gain
U.S. multinational corporations with foreign tax exposure; U.S. domestic corporations competing against foreign firms; U.S. investors in foreign real estate and securities