Federal abortion-provider criminal law targets practice that doesn't appear to exist
H.R. 4131 — Respectful Treatment of Unborn Remains Act of 2025 · Filed by Brandon Gill (R-TX) · 5 cosponsors · Introduced Jun 25, 2025 · Referred to committee
Your members of Congress
Enter a ZIP to see where your representative and both senators stood on this bill.
Looked up on this device — your ZIP is never stored on our servers.
What it does
This bill makes it a federal crime for abortion providers to dispose of fetal remains by placing them into public water systems (sewers, treatment plants, etc.). Violators face up to 5 years in prison and fines. The bill does not hold the pregnant person liable. It allows states and localities to impose stricter rules.
Why we flagged it
The bill's functional purpose is not to solve a documented water-system or public-health problem, but to create federal criminal penalties for abortion providers. The specific prohibition (fetal remains in sewers) appears to target a non-existent or vanishingly rare practice, suggesting the bill's true aim is symbolic criminalization of abortion rather than environmental or health protection.
What the text implies
- Creates federal criminal liability for abortion providers even where state law permits abortion, potentially conflicting with state-law protections and creating a federal enforcement mechanism against abortion care.
- The definition of 'fetal remains' includes 'any other medical waste associated with an abortion,' which is extremely broad and could encompass routine medical materials, creating prosecutorial discretion and chilling effects on abortion provision.
The full analysis lists 4 implications of this text.
Who it affects
The bill criminalizes a practice that appears not to occur in standard medical care (fetal remains are typically incinerated or handled as medical waste through licensed disposal, not flushed into sewers). It creates federal criminal liability for abortion providers without addressing any documented public-health problem, effectively using criminal law as a messaging tool against abortion rather than protecting public health or water systems.